Merkur 23C vs Fatip Retro: Which Safety Razor Wins?

Quick answer

Choose the Merkur 23C if you want a forgiving, closed-comb razor with a long handle for easy reach. Pick the Fatip Retro if you prefer an open comb head that handles longer stubble and offers a more traditional feel. Both are well-made, affordable options for wet shavers.

Tradeoffs to consider

• Closed comb vs open comb: The Merkur 23C’s closed comb is more forgiving and reduces irritation for beginners or daily shavers. The Fatip Retro’s open comb cuts through longer hair more efficiently but requires a lighter touch to avoid nicks. Daily shaver? Choose Merkur 23C. Weekend shaver? Fatip Retro.
• Handle length and grip: Merkur 23C has a 4-inch long handle for extended reach. Fatip Retro’s handle is also long but thinner, with a ball-end that some find more secure. The best grip depends on your hand size and shaving angle. Try both if possible; the handle feel is a personal preference.
• Weight and balance: At 62 grams, the Merkur 23C is slightly heavier than the Fatip Retro (exact weight not specified). Heavier razors can provide more momentum for a smooth cut, but lighter razors offer more control for precise areas. Merkur 23C is better for a weighted, effortless stroke. Fatip Retro suits a lighter, more hands-on technique.

Product facts

• Merkur 23C Long Handle Double Edge Safety Razor: The Merkur 23C Long Handle Double Edge Safety Razor offers a classic shaving experience with a design focused on comfort and control. Crafted in Germany, this razor is a reliable choice for those who appreciate traditional wet shaving. Long handle design provides a comfortable grip and extended reach for easier maneuvering. Weighs 2.2 oz (62 g) for a balanced feel during use. Measures 4 inches (10 cm) in length. The long handle gives you extra reach, which is helpful for shaving the back of the neck or for users with larger hands. The moderate weight keeps the razor steady without feeling heavy.
• Fatip Retro Double Edge Safety Razor - Chrome(42118): Fatip Retro Double Edge Safety Razor - Chrome (Cromato) The Fatip RETRO Safety Razor is the brand new “3 piece razor” recently introduced in the market. Its long and thin handle, with elegant engraving and a ball-end, gives a very comfortable grip. Like the classic line, the RETRO is a well-balanced easy to use razor. The open comb head ensures that the razor will work well with differing lengths of beard growth. The open comb head is ideal if you don't shave daily—it can handle a few days of growth without clogging. The engraved handle adds a vintage look and improves grip when wet.

Which one fits you?

Best for

• New wet shavers who want a forgiving, easy-to-use safety bar razor
• Anyone who shaves daily and values extended reach from a long handle

Not for

• Those who prefer a very lightweight razor or want an open comb to handle multi-day stubble